Top 5 Best Sandwich Maker 2018 – Buyer’s Guide & Reviews

Top 5 Best Sandwich Maker 2018 – Buyer’s Guide & Reviews
5 (100%) 4 votes

Sandwiches are such a healthy and delicious treat to start your day. It is one of the most common snacks to make your lunch more interesting. It is also easy to prepare at your home if you have some of the best sandwich recipes. Today, we are going to discuss some of the best rated sandwich makers available on Amazon, which are durable, efficient and user friendly.

Sandwich makers are supposed to be the best kitchen accessories which make your breakfast more special. The sandwich makers listed here are known for their best performance and durability.

Buyer’s Guide – What to Look For?

Deep Fill

Toasted sandwich makers that are deep fill are relatively new in the market. Deep fill feature is a must in your sandwich maker if you want to make more sandwich recipes than just a cheese sandwich and a ham. To make large sandwiches, be sure to have a sprung top plate.

Dishwasher Safe Plates

Keep in mind that all toasted sandwich makers don’t come with dishwasher safe and removable plates. It means you need to wipe out the burnt scraps after disconnecting the machine. So, it is the important feature in a toasted sandwich maker.


Look for the toasted sandwich makers that come with Panini and waffle attachments. These are identical plates which can make it a 3-in-one device. Make sure the toasted sandwich maker is versatile enough to make a ciabatta, fresh waffle, and Panini along with toasted sandwich.

Temperature Control

It is another important feature that is common only in semi-pro and fully professional models. It is the best appliance to use plates for different use along with just a good toasted sandwich. This feature comes in handy if you are looking for the expensive models.

Vertical Storage

Small space is such a big issue in your kitchen. If you are not going to use toasted sandwich maker day by day, you need to look for the one that you can store in vertical form.

Best Buy Sandwich Maker Reviews 2018

1. Hamilton Beach 25475A Breakfast Sandwich Maker

Hamilton Beach Breakfast Sandwich Maker

Buy From Amazon

Hamilton Beach has been the most reputed brand over the years for making best-in-class kitchen appliances trusted by millions of housewives and professional chefs. The 25475A breakfast sandwich maker is one of the best. This premium device can start your day with well made sandwiches within just 5 minutes. It is the best deal for those whose schedules remain busy with 9-5 jobs.

This appliance can save a lot on market-bought sandwiches. If you don’t like the oily sandwiches in cafes and restaurants, this quality sandwich maker is truly versatile as you can make different recipes with your favorite ingredients. It is also easy to make small bagels and biscuits. Some products need a lot of technical know how. Luckily, this sandwich maker comes with convenient design. You need to have a free wall outlet to use it. It is also great to use non-stick pan in it to cut the risk of getting burnt sandwiches. It has got all the detachable dishwasher safe parts so you won’t have to work hard on cleanup.

Some brands use low-quality materials due to which they break down after weeks. But there is no so in case of Hamilton Beach 25475A. it has high quality components to improve its performance and longevity.


  • Dishwasher safe components
  • Easy to make sandwiches within five minutes
  • Indicator lights to notify you when your sandwich is ready
  • Made of quality materials to ensure longevity


  • Many users ended up with under cooked egg

2. Hamilton Beach 25490A Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker

Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker

Buy From Amazon

Now you no longer need to wait too long to cook your sandwiches. It’s time to throw your old-school sandwich maker that cook just one sandwich at a time.  Hamilton 25490A dual sandwich maker can make it easy and fast to make two sandwiches at a time within five minutes. You can get well cooked sandwich makers with this daily sandwich maker.

If you don’t like the cold sandwiches that are delivered from your nearest restaurant and if you are bored with same recipes that they use every time, Hamilton Beach 25490A helps you try different recipes with endless options. Use eggs and cheese to make different types of sandwiches every day. It cooks well-formed recipes which won’t crumble.

Unlike other brands which needs for different ingredients, Hamilton Beach 25490A Dual has got convenient cooking slots. Layer your ingredients quickly without getting them spilled on the shelves. It has dishwasher safe non-stick plates that are removable as well. So, there is no need to work hard on cooking and cleaning up. It also has handy alert timer to notify you when sandwiches are cooked.

Hamilton Beach is a reputed brand which makes top quality sandwich makers which won’t break down easily. Both its housing and plates are made of durable material. Also the components like on board controls and hinges are durable and won’t degrade so early.


  • Cooks sandwiches within five minutes
  • Cooks two sandwiches at a time
  • Audible timer with tone to alert you
  • Easy to use controls


  • Lacks on/off switch

3. Cuisinart Dual-Sandwich Nonstick Electric Grill

Cuisinart Dual-Sandwich Nonstick Electric Grill

Buy From Amazon

Do you want varieties in your daily breakfast like toasts, sandwiches, and omelets as snacks or breakfasts? Buy Cuisinart Dual-Sandwich Electric non-stick grill to make the well-cooked grilled sandwiches at home. It has non-stick plates which also cook omelets and toasts. It has indicator lights to alert you when cooking.

It is the best choice for those who want to serve many family members within no time for breakfast. Don’t want to order pre-cooked restaurant-made sandwiches? Cuisinart offers dual sandwich grill which comes to the rescue. It has deep pocket design which is capable to cook around two delightful sandwiches at a time. It has got non-stick and durable pockets which can slice sandwiches when cooking. It can make your breakfast more fun and simple as you won’t need professional cooking skills.

Cuisinart is another reputable kitchen appliances brand which is known for quality you can trust. This sandwich maker has quality components and housing. The grill plates are non-stick so you won’t get burnt sandwiches. All you need to use paper fluff-free towel or just a clean and damp towel for easy cleanup.

This compact sandwich maker measures just 9x9x3.5 inches in dimensions. If you are running low on space in your kitchen, it is the best and handy appliance with lockable lid. Simply store it upright without any worry. It also comes with 3 years of manufacturer’s warranty, so you can replace it if you get the defected product. Cook your favorite French toast or omelets along with sandwiches and save more on costly breakfast.


  • Space-efficient and compact design
  • Indicator lights are bright to alert you
  • Great choice to make delicious omelets and sandwiches
  • Non-stick plates that are easy to cleanup
  • Comes with three years of warranty


  • Pockets are somewhat shallow

4. Z&Z S6141A-B 4 in 1 Breakfast Waffle Omelette and Sandwich Maker

Z&Z Breakfast Waffle Omelette and Sandwich Maker

Buy From Amazon

If you are looking for a kitchen appliance that is handy and easy to use, ZZ S6141A-B is designed to save even more time as it can cook up to four breakfast sandwiches at once. If you want innovative way of cooking, this device is just for you. It is built with superior design.

Z&Z is a reputed brand headquartered in Delaware which has designed this appliance with Chinese and American style teams. So, you can find unique designs that can complement both Western and Chinese culture to serve the needs of every homemaker.


  • Non-stick, dishwasher safe, removable plates that are easy to cook sandwiches and cleanup
  • Pre-heat and power indicators to alert you of ideal temperature control
  • Non-stick baking sheet to cook with proper control


  • Waffle plates won’t fit over time
  • Made of low quality materials

5. Proctor-Silex 2540IP Sandwich Maker

Proctor Sandwich Maker

Buy From Amazon

When it comes to sandwich makers, first thing you want is easy preparation and safety. Not all brands create sandwich makers that are made equally and all cannot serve your need. Proctor-Silex makes premium items to meet your needs. If you love sandwiches, it is among the best sandwich makers money can buy. It can save a lot of time for you.

Most people have complaints with low-quality pans that are annoying to make pastries as breads are burned and stick. Some materials use phthalates and BPA for non-stick coating but it affects the food quality. Thankfully, Proctor-Silex has removed all such issues. It has both phthalates and BPA free cooking pans which are also non-stick. So, you have nothing to worry about cooking different varieties of sandwiches.

Timing matters the most while cooking healthy and delightful sandwiches. There is a lot of risk in burning sandwiches if you exceed your time. Poor timing is the main reason behind undercooked or uncooked sandwiches. Forget all the woes with Proctor-Silex sandwich maker thanks to its non-stick pan. It has preheat and on/off indicator to keep track on your cooking process. It has become the most preferred choice for wannabe chefs and cooking enthusiasts.

This sandwich maker is also easy to store thanks to its compact design which avoids clutter on cupboards and shelves. It has tight fitting lid and cord warp to store without any problem. But guide is confusing for beginners and it doesn’t have booklet. It is among the best when it comes to performance and non-stick pan, and BPA free accessories. The odds of burning or sticking sandwiches are minimal.


  • Non-stick pan to avoid burns
  • Built-in cord wrap to save space
  • BPA-free coating to avoid health issues
  • Pre-heat and power indicators


  • No cooking guide and booklets

How to Clean Sandwich Maker?

If you have a sandwich maker and if you wondering how to clean the sandwich maker properly then do not worry and simply follow the steps mentioned below

  • First of all, unplug the sandwich maker and if you just finished using the sandwich maker then wait for it to cool down.
  • Now, use a plastic spatula or something not very hard to remove the dry crumbs from the sandwich maker. Ensure that you are not using something sharp as this can destroy the non-stick coating on the sandwich maker.
  • Take a sponge or a towel and wet it with the warm water. Squeeze out the excess water and then simply start wiping the plates of the sandwich maker. Ensure that there is not much of water on the sponge as the water can damage the electrical components of the sandwich maker.
  • Now, use a dry napkin or a towel to wipe off the water or the moisture from the surface of the plates of the sandwich maker and let it dry for a couple of minutes before you use it again.
  • If your sandwich maker comes with removable plates then you can simply remove those plates and put them in the dishwasher to clean the plates. The process is quite simple and easy to follow. It is always better to have sandwich maker with the removable plates as the cleaning process becomes really easy. Once the plates are dry, you can simply put them back into the toaster.

This is how you can clean the sandwich maker in your kitchen and you must clean the sandwich maker after every use or else there could be build-up on the plates which can contaminate your food and make you seriously ill. Do not forget to follow precautions while cleaning the sandwich maker.


Listed above are the top rated sandwich makers from bestselling brands on Amazon. We hope you will like them because these durable products are reviewed after a lot of research. They come with durable materials and are affordable. If you love delicious sandwiches, omelets, or French toasts, you will definitely like these appliances.